Editorial illustration of medical records and a magnifying glass against a neutral hospital corridor in muted blue-grey tones.

Scottish Government orders review of response to NHS Grampian surgery concerns

Last updated: Reading time: 2 min

The Scottish Government has commissioned an urgent, independent review of how concerns about surgical safety at NHS Grampian were handled. According to the BBC, the decision follows the disclosure of a 2022 report which found that 19 of the 31 patient deaths it examined were potentially avoidable.

Scottish health minister Angela Constance announced the review on 21 November. It will examine the actions of both NHS Grampian — a regional health board in Scotland — and the Scottish Government. Its scope includes their response to concerns about liver, gallbladder and bile duct surgery, including those raised by surgeon Mohammed Habib, and to the 2022 report.

What the independent review will examine

The BBC reports that the review will seek to identify weaknesses in oversight, missed opportunities to intervene, unjustified delays and gaps in accountability. It will therefore consider not only what concerns were raised, but also how institutions assessed them and made decisions.

Habib says he repeatedly alerted the Scottish Government to concerns about patient safety. According to the BBC, he also approached the police and the Lord Advocate, Scotland’s most senior prosecutor.

The 2022 report disclosed by the surgeon examined deaths in cases involving liver and pancreatic surgery. It is that document which, according to the BBC, assessed 19 of the 31 deaths examined as potentially avoidable. This is not a finding of the newly commissioned review, nor does it refer to new deaths recorded on the day the review was announced.

Concerns requiring action to be referred without delay

According to the BBC, the Scottish Government said matters requiring action by the relevant authorities, including any potential criminal concerns, would be referred without waiting for the final report. That commitment does not in itself establish that a crime has occurred or that a specific criminal investigation has begun.

At the time of the BBC’s report, the review’s leadership and timetable were still due to be set out in the Scottish Parliament. Its findings are not yet known: the review will examine whether the institutional response to the safety concerns was appropriate and where failings may have occurred.

Sources

Found an error or outdated information? Let us know.

Latest posts